Uppereast.com
Fri Feb 10, 2012
Local Businesses
User login
Join our mailing list
Login/Register
| Home | Search | Yorkville | Carnegie Hill | Lenox Hill | Sutton Place | About Us | Mobile | Subscriptions
Brother Jimmy's Bait Shack
Address: 1644 3rd Avenue
Block: 3rd Avenue between 92nd & 93rd
Phone: 212-426-2020
Website: http://www.brotherjimmys.com
Features: Barbecue,Food,Get Sloppy,Sports,Happy Hour
NYC Dept of Health Violations Link: - View Report
Yelp users give Brother Jimmy's Bait Shack an overall rating of 3.5 based on 67 total reviews.
Christina H. says "As a Sourthern girl myself I love me some good BBQ. My company ordered in for us today and I tasted quite a sampler of mac and cheese, bbq chicken, mashed......read more
Scottie K. says "Didn't love it. The southern style sweet tea was pathetic. It had no ice, it was NOT sweet and no lemon. Brother Jimmy's is like a ChinaTown knock off of......read more
John R. says "Will never go back. Food came out cold. Waitress never came by. Had one beer. Finished it. Got another 40 minutes later when the waitress came back.......read more
Citysearch users give Brother Jimmy's Bait Shack an overall rating of 8 out of 10 based on 47 total reviews. Reminds me of Growing up in the South! ( - Jessica Lynn rates it 8 out of 10) - My cousin brought me here last summer after I moved to NYC from Florida. They were playing country music and I was instantly reminded of home! Whenever I'm craving some fried, southern food I head there. ...read more Top 10 BBQ in the city ( - EyeGuy rates it 8 out of 10) - I heard a lot about Brother Jimmy's before I tried it recently. I heard the service was terrible and the atmosphere was a little like a frat house. I ended up sitting at the bar to try their ribs so I really can't comment on the… ...read more
Great Experience ( - maribel1081 rates it 10 out of 10) - Great Staff, Great Food, Great Prices! After a horrible experiece at the 77th St location... this location was a pleasant surprise! Will definately go back again! ...read more