Eleni's New York

Food, Dining & Nightlife » Bakeries

Address: 1266 Madison Avenue
Block: Madison Avenue between 90th & 91st
Phone: 888-435-3647
Website: http://www.elenis.com/
Rating:

Average: 2 (1 vote)

Profile
Announcements
Events
Reviews
Editorials
Photos
Videos
Links
Discounts
Menu

Yelp users give Eleni's New York an overall rating of 3 based on 6 total reviews.

elaine s. says "This place is so lame. Staff is unfriendly. They charged me too much for my drink and neglected to tell me about their happy hour special. Buy one get one......read more

Heather C. says "not a good as billy's, but great when you need a cupcake fix...read more

Kelly E. says "total win. having lived in new york my entire life, i'll go ahead and say it - i'm pretty much a cupcake expert. i've done the magnolias, the crumbs, and......read more

Local Businesses

Local Perspectives

Quick Links

User login

Join our mailing list

Eleni's New York

	High on Decoration, Low on Flavor - Eleni's is home to the perfectly decorated, kitschy, customizable cookie. Unfortunately the cookies fall short on flavor. A chocolate chip cookie has a cardboard taste and a consistency that is in that in-between spot of neither soft and chewy nor deliciously crunchy. The sugar cookies share the same cardboard taste; they simply do not taste sugary and the icing is flavorless. The cupcakes are Eleni's only saving grace; they actually have flavor and the icing is light, whipped and sweet. The vanilla on vanilla cupcake tastes like a Twinkie. If you plan to visit Eleni's during the summer, be prepared for the shortened summer hours- Eleni's closes at 6 p.m. on weekdays and is frequently closed on summer weekends.