Mon Mar 30, 2015

Local Businesses

User login

Join our mailing list

  Login/Register | Home | Search | Yorkville | Carnegie Hill | Lenox Hill | Sutton Place | About Us | Mobile | Subscriptions


Address: 1305 Madison Avenue
Block: Madison Avenue between 92nd & 93rd
Phone: 212-996-1200
Features: New American,Happy Hour
NYC Dept of Health Violations Link: - View Report

Yelp users give Island an overall rating of 3 based on 39 total reviews.

John B. says "I thought this place was very good. Atmosphere was lively and fun with a well heeled very mixed crowd, bankers, brokers, hedgefunders etc. and their wives &......read more

J M. says "great atmosphere, service and food! I want to come back asap- we had the lobster quesadilla, caesar salad, sausage rigatoni and burger. All were amazing!!...read more

leslie d. says "We try this restaurant every couple of years as we live a block away and so want to like it! The food, amotsphere (smells like a fish shack), and service......read more

  Citysearch users give Island an overall rating of 8 out of 10 based on 8 total reviews.

  Exquisite! ( - Keveya & K rates it 10 out of 10) - Very nice restaurant. The atomsphere is something out of a movie. From the lighting to the way the tables are arranged. Pricey-yes, worth it- yes! Very romantic, nice place to go on a date! ...read more

  Great menu selection ( - Iris W rates it 8 out of 10) - I really liked eating at Island. Great ambiance when you walk in the door, friendly waitstaff. Their menu is very diverse and has lots to choose from. Their pasta is especially good - would love to go back to try out their brunch. ...read more

  Great dining and comfortable after the musuem ( - mvorel1128 rates it 10 out of 10) - This is a great place to take your spouse or date for dinner. The fish dishes are superb. It is very convenient after touring a museum. We visit here oftern with our friends as this restaurant is quiet enough to have a converstaion… ...read more