Uppereast.com
Fri May 25, 2012
Local Businesses
User login
Join our mailing list
Login/Register
| Home | Search | Yorkville | Carnegie Hill | Lenox Hill | Sutton Place | About Us | Mobile | Subscriptions
Ottomanelli's Cafe
Address: 1626 York Avenue
Block: York Avenue between 85th & 86th
Phone: 212-772-7722
Website: http://www.nycotto.com
Features: Italian
Yelp users give Ottomanelli's Cafe an overall rating of 3.5 based on 57 total reviews.
Sara N. says "Oh yum yum in the tum tum The first amazing thing about this place is the BYO without a corkage fee. BF and I walked in with our bottle of wine and as soon......read more
Ali C. says "Oh this place. Even though I live and die for Otto's butcher shop, I was hesitant about trying the cafe since it had a "B" rating. However, it recently......read more
Eva G. says "It's comfortable here; you feel like you're in a small local neighborhood family-owned diner that has no more than 10-15 tables. Some people dine solo and......read more
Citysearch users give Ottomanelli's Cafe an overall rating of 8 out of 10 based on 3 total reviews. affordable AND tasty ( - eksuh rates it 8 out of 10) - it's rare to find good byo's in the city, so this was great! my roommate and i brought a bottle of wine and ordered some tasty italian food. the pizza's decent, but i prefer the steak sandwiches. ...read more
Stood the test of time ( - Millie G rates it 6 out of 10) - Ottomanelli's has been around forever, and their food hasn't changed much. The pizza isn't very good, but their pasta and burgers are good comfort food. And the waffle fries are well-known for a reason! ...read more
Hide-away on the Upper East Side ( - shortstuf rates it 10 out of 10) - Although this restaurant was listed in all of our EATS and We Deliver magazines I had never ventured to it until recently. I was pleasantly surprised to find a small, cozy, inexpensive gem right in the neighborhood. The portions are… ...read more