Uppereast.com
Fri May 25, 2012
Local Businesses
User login
Join our mailing list
Login/Register
| Home | Search | Yorkville | Carnegie Hill | Lenox Hill | Sutton Place | About Us | Mobile | Subscriptions
Petaluma Restaurant
Address: 1356 1st Ave
Block: 1st Avenue between 72nd & 73rd
Phone: 212-772-8800
Website: http://www.petalumarestaurant.com
Features: Italian
NYC Dept of Health Violations Link: - View Report
Yelp users give Petaluma Restaurant an overall rating of 3.5 based on 41 total reviews.
Dori D. says "This is literally the best pizza in New York City. That's what my native friend told me my first day in the city. He took me here and told me I should......read more
L E. says "Had the special Gnocchi in a pink sauce - was delish. This is a very nice restaurant and to me was the perfect place for a date. The tables are not too......read more
Mike J. says "Sitting here waiting on my sea bass for 45mins. They must be out catching it. Brought me the wrong soup. Had to send it back. Decent martini. Over priced......read more
Citysearch users give Petaluma Restaurant an overall rating of 9 out of 10 based on 14 total reviews.
I love this restaurant ( - Fanny K rates it 10 out of 10) - I remember eating here for the first time, approximately 15 years ago and being blown away by the subtle elegant seasonings and absolutely delicious food. It is rather expensive so a visit here may have to be saved for a special occasion… ...read more
Excellent Italian food.. from pizza's to home made dishes. ( - Stuart S rates it 8 out of 10) - The food at Petaluma is truly the best Italian food I've had since arriving in NY 3 weeks ago. The only problem is the cost. It's about 3 times the cost of going a couple of doors down to get a pizza and some pasta. However, for a night… ...read more good for the kids ( - Anonymous rates it 8 out of 10) - kid friendly staff. large choice menu. reasonably good prices. large good looking interior. make a reservation if you will be a large party or have a special request. ...read more